Man wanted in 2023 Atlanta music studio murder arrested in Coweta

Published November 11, 2026 10:57 AM EST

Federal authorities captured an Atlanta Police Most Wanted murder suspect Tuesday morning in Coweta County, ending a yearslong manhunt for the gunman accused of killing an unarmed man outside a music studio.

What we know:

FBI Atlanta's Violent Crime Task Force arrested Mi'Quae Williams Tuesday morning at a home in Sharpsburg.

The Atlanta Police Department, the Coweta County Sheriff's Office and the Georgia State Patrol assisted federal agents with the morning operation.

Investigators charged Williams in connection with the fatal shooting of 23-year-old Nicholas Carter outside the aBs Music Studio on Ralph David Abernathy Boulevard.

Nicholas Carter

The shooting occurred on Sept. 16, 2023, when gunfire erupted just as Carter stepped out of his car.

Emergency medical workers rushed Carter to a local hospital, but he died from his injuries.

Prior to Tuesday's capture, authorities had offered a $5,000 Crime Stoppers reward for information leading to an arrest.

What they're saying:

FOX 5's Aungelique Proctor spoke with Carter's father, Scott Carter, who said he had prayed for this day and broke down in tears when he learned of the arrest. Still, he said the pain of losing his only son remains constant and has taken a toll on his own health.

"It will never be over because that was my son," Scott Carter said. "It never goes away. It aches. It aches every day."

He maintained that his son was targeted for no reason.

"After Nick died, that's when my health started going down," he said. "He was killed for nothing. I know my son. He wasn't selling drugs. He wasn't starting something."

Nicholas' parents also shared a direct message to Williams following his capture: "Tell the truth. You caught now. Tell the truth. It's OK."

The backstory:

The fatal violence unfolded outside the music studio when Carter arrived for a recording session.

Police stated Carter had just exited his vehicle before bullets started flying.

Investigators soon identified Williams as the accused shooter, yet years passed without custody.

Both parents remembered Carter as a kindhearted young man drawn to rap music who was carrying no weapons when attacked.

The family often questioned whether someone targeted their son in a tragic case of mistaken identity.

RELATED

What we don't know:

Authorities have not revealed what led investigators to the specific Coweta County home where they captured Williams.

Officials also have not released an official motive for the deadly gunfire outside the southwest Atlanta building.

Carter's parents repeatedly noted that detectives told them their son had zero connection or affiliation with Williams.

The Source: The information in this story was gathered from the Federal Bureau of Investigation Atlanta field office, who confirmed the capture on social media, as well as prior reporting and statements from the Atlanta Police Department and the victim's family.

Coweta CountyAtlantaCrime and Public SafetyNews