Atlanta's Catholic leadership react to selection of American for pope

Excitement and pride filled the offices of the Archdiocese of Atlanta on Thursday as staff and clergy gathered to witness a moment of history: the announcement of Cardinal Robert Prevost as Pope Leo XIV, the first American ever elected to lead the Catholic Church.

What began as a regular meeting at the archdiocese’s Smyrna headquarters quickly turned into a watch party as the white smoke from the Vatican signaled that the conclave had chosen a new pope. Moments later, the historic announcement was made.

RELATED STORIES

What they're saying:

Archbishop Gregory Hartmayer addressed the significance of the moment, calling it both monumental and unexpected. "It was unexpected," said Archbishop Gregory Hartmayer. "I said, ‘Oh my goodness, we have a native English-speaking pope,’ which will be wonderful for us Americans."

Hailing the appointment as a long shot that paid off, Hartmayer said he believes Leo XIV will follow in the footsteps of his predecessor, Pope Francis, particularly in his commitment to the poor and marginalized.

"He’s an excellent choice," Hartmayer said. "He’s a moderate."

Parishioner Kel Harper also welcomed the news. "I thought it was pretty neat that he was American," Harper said. "I think it’s a good choice."

"It’s huge, it’s very exciting to hear," said Olivia Lucero outside the Cathedral of Christ the King. "I have a lot of hope for the Holy Father," she added. "He’ll be ferocious in defending the faith."

What we know:

Pope Leo XIV, a member of the Augustinian order, spent much of his pastoral career ministering in Peru and previously led the Vatican’s powerful Office of Bishops. The Augustinians emphasize community and unity, guided by the principle: "live together in harmony, being one of mind and one heart on the way to God."

In celebration of the historic appointment, the Cathedral of Christ the King in Atlanta held a special service on Thursday evening.

What's next:

For the Archdiocese of Atlanta and Catholics across the U.S., the elevation of an American to the papacy is a moment of pride and reflection—an event sure to remain at the center of conversation for days to come.

AtlantaReligionNews