2 men first cleared in fatal road-rage shooting now charged along with 2 others amid new details from lawsuit
Weldon Boyd (left) and Kenneth Williams (right) have been charged with murder in the September 2023 shooting death of Scott Spivey, according to court records. (Photo: Horry County Detention Center)
Two men who prosecutors initially cleared in a deadly 2023 shooting in South Carolina on the state’s "Stand Your Ground" law have now been charged with murder and a pair of former law enforcement officers are also charged in connection with the crime.
What we know:
Weldon Boyd and Kenneth Williams now face murder charges in the September 2023 shooting of Scott Spivey.
Two former Horry County officers, former Horry County Deputy Chief Brandon Strickland and Sgt. Damon Vescovi, were indicted on charges of obstruction of justice and misconduct for their role in the investigation.
Two former Horry County officers, Deputy Chief Brandon Strickland (left) and Sgt. Damon Vescovi (right), were indicted on charges of obstruction of justice and misconduct in the investigation into the shooting, court documents state.(Photo: Horry Cou
Dig deeper:
At the time, authorities told reporters that Boyd and Williams chased Spivey for several miles after Spivey pulled a gun on them in a road rage incident.
High-speed chase led to shooting
Both pickup trucks reached speeds in excess of 100 mph during the chase, investigators said, before Spivey pulled off onto a side road, got out of his truck and told the men to stop following him.
But the men show through the windshield of the pickup truck, hitting Spivey in the right side of his back.
Prosecutors clear the 2 men in the shooting
In August 2025, South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson declined to charge Boyd and Williams, saying the state’s "Stand Your Ground" law applied.
"The legal analysis of this case was reviewed by multiple career prosecutors within the Office of the Attorney General, who all reached the same conclusion," Wilson said in a statement. "We have continued to review all information and evidence provided to us by law enforcement, including eyewitness statements, toxicology reports, video evidence and forensic analysis. Our analysis has remained the same."
Under the law, formally known as the South Carolina Protection of Persons and Property Act, people have the right to defend themselves if they "reasonably believe they are in imminent danger," and that "immunity from prosecution is provided in certain circumstances where the use of deadly force is deemed lawful," the statement continued.
Family uncovers evidence after prosecutor’s decision
Spivey’s sister, Jennifer Spivey, pursued a civil case against the two men, and in the process of building the case, she received new evidence, the Associated Press reported.
That evidence included recordings Boyd made of his phone calls in which he bragged about the shooting and asked a police officer to intervene, the AP reported. In another call, Boyd reportedly talked to Williams about them getting teardrop tattoos since they killed a man.
In another call, Boyd was heard telling someone, "I know it’s (expletive) up to say, but I had a (expletive) blast," the AP reported.
Other evidence included body camera footage of another officer writing a note to the men the day of the shooting that read, "act like victim camera."
The Horry County Sheriff’s Office fired the two officers after learning of the new evidence and the Attorney General’s Office launched a new investigation which led to this week’s indictments.
Officers indicted for their conduct during investigation
Prosecutors said Boyd called Strickland several times from the scene of the deadly confrontation and later, and Strickland responded that he spoke with investigators and prosecutors about the case, according to Boyd’s phone records.
What they're saying:
Lawyers for all four men have said their clients are innocent and Shaun Kent, who represents Boyd, said the charges should be dropped in part because the evidence from the victim case was used to build criminal charges.
One of the reasons the attorney general’s office cleared the men, Kent said, was that Spivey had alcohol in his system at the time of the chase.
"He was intoxicated. He had a firearm. He was pointing it at other individuals," King said in court.
Strickland’s attorney said at this week’s bond hearing that while his comments may have been inappropriate, there was no evidence that they actually influenced the investigation.
Vescovi was accused of passing the note to the two about the camera. His attorney told the bond court judge that Vescovi made a poor choice, but at that point, he believe Boyd and Williams were victims of a road rage incident.
Jennifer Spivey asked the judge to make sure justice is finally served.
"Scott tried desperately to escape the violence that ultimately took his life," she said.
The judge set bond for all four men this week, WPDE-TV reported. Boyd’s bond was set at $110,000; Williams’ at $100,000; and Strickland’s and Vescovi’s at $10,000 each.
The Source: Information in this story came from the Associated Press, the South Carolina Attorney General's Office and WPDE. This story was reported from Orlando.