Tyler Robinson: Judge holds prosecutor in civil contempt, keeps death penalty on table

PROVO, Utah - Tyler Robinson, the man accused of fatally shooting Charlie Kirk in September 2025, appeared in court Friday for a virtual hearing, where a judge issued a mixed ruling on allegations that prosecutors violated a pretrial publicity order.

Why you should care:

Judge Tony Graf Jr. found Utah County prosecutor Christopher Ballard in civil contempt for publicly stating there was "ample evidence" to prove Robinson's guilt before trial. However, the judge did not hold Ballard in contempt for making public statements correcting what prosecutors said were misleading reports about an ATF ballistics analysis.

RELATED: Charlie Kirk bullet match analysis prompts defense to ask for prelim delay

The judge also rejected the defense's request to bar prosecutors from seeking the death penalty, allowing capital punishment to remain a possible sentence if Robinson is convicted.

Dig deeper:

The controversy centered on an ATF ballistics report. Robinson's attorneys argued the agency could not identify the bullet recovered during Charlie Kirk's autopsy as having been fired from the rifle allegedly used in the shooting.

Prosecutors responded publicly that the defense had omitted important context. While the bullet was too damaged to be conclusively matched to the rifle, the ATF also could not exclude the rifle as the source, and the bullet's caliber was consistent with the suspected murder weapon.

RELATED: Charlie Kirk murder: Judge rules cameras allowed in courtroom for Tyler Robinson trial

During the hearing, Utah County Attorney Jeff Gray testified that the prosecution's public comments were intended only to "set the record straight" after what his office viewed as misleading public reporting.

Judge Graf agreed that prosecutors were permitted to correct the public record regarding the ATF findings and declined to hold Ballard in contempt over those statements.

However, the judge ruled Ballard crossed the line when he publicly stated there was "ample evidence" proving Robinson's guilt, finding that statement violated the court's pretrial publicity order. Graf held Ballard in civil contempt but declined to impose the defense's requested sanction of striking the death penalty.

The backstory:

Prosecutors intend to seek the death penalty if Robinson, 23, is convicted. He is charged with crimes including aggravated murder in the Sept. 10 assassination of the conservative activist on the Utah Valley University campus. Robinson has not yet entered a plea.

Prior to his death, Kirk and the conservative youth movement he founded, Turning Point USA, emerged as a major force in U.S. politics and helped President Donald Trump win a second term.

Prosecutors have said Robinson left a note for his romantic partner that read, "I had the opportunity to take out Charlie Kirk and I’m going to take it." They have also said he wrote in a text message about Kirk: "I had enough of his hatred. Some hate can’t be negotiated out."

RELATED: Tyler Robinson hearing: Judge denies request to seal evidence in Charlie Kirk murder case

What's next:

Graf Jr. declined to remove the death penalty as a possible punishment. Instead, he said the court will consider expanded jury selection procedures to help ensure Robinson receives a fair trial despite the pretrial publicity.

Graf also ordered that Robinson's defense be reimbursed for the costs it incurred in pursuing the civil contempt motion against prosecutor Christopher Ballard.

The ruling comes ahead of a key hearing scheduled to begin July 6, when prosecutors must show they have enough evidence to warrant a trial. That would mark the most significant presentation of evidence to date in the case, which has so far focused on matters of media access.